Help – someone stole my idea!

Help – someone stole my idea!

By Rajesh Setty on Tue 22 Aug 2006, 12:55 PM – 10 Comments

I have written about this before and probably will write more before the end of the year. Here is some background:

Being in Silicon Valley, it it not hard for me to meet with different types of people at entrepreneurship related conferences. Most of them fall under the four categories below:

a) successful entrepreneurs

b) entrepreneurs who think they are successful

c) people who want to be entrepreneurs

d) people who think they want to be entrepreneurs

The last category has everything. They are the most interesting, amusing and frustrating people that I encounter.They are smart people and probably are very successful in their current jobs. They have interesting ideas (sometimes) to build busiensses on but unfortunately, they don’t have the heart of an entrepreneur. Here are the kinds of comments they open their introduction with:

a) “Raj, you must have read Google’s recent announcement on <fill in the blank>. I had that idea three years ago”

b) “In some sense Yahoo! stole my idea”

c) “I had the very same idea last year. I even told this to some of my friends. Microsoft beat me to it”

Honestly, I don’t know how to respond to those kinds of comments. When I learn a bit more about them, it is clear to me that they were not going to do anything with those ideas anyways. In fact, my big worry is that they currently have some ideas cooking in their minds – won’t do a thing with them and three years later repeat the same story with someone else.

Here are my $.02 on this topic

1. You may not be the only person to get that idea

Something at work or outside triggered some thoughts that led to an “Aha moment” and that led to a business idea. Your assessment was that you “observed” something that others didn’t. It does not take a lot of time to realize that this is very unlikely that you are the ONLY person to have got that idea in the world. Unless it is some sort of a breakthrough idea, you actually be confident that many more people in the world have got the VERY same “million dollar idea” in their minds.

2. Majority of people who get an idea won’t do a thing with it

While the #1 item above is bit discouraging, the good part is that most people who get ideas won’t do a thing about it. There are many reasons for this. Here are some:

a) They don’t want to do anything with ideas. They just like to stretch their creativity

b) Most often, executing on an idea requires a “lot more work” than conceiving that idea

c) People move on to the next idea. That is more fun!

3. What you do with the idea is equally important as the idea itself

Unless you are cooking up ideas for academic purposes, an idea ALONE may not be worth much. You got to execute on it. Here are four combinations that I can think of

a) Bad Idea + Bad Execution (Clueless category)
b) Bad Idea + Good Execution (Over-confident category)
c) Good Idea + Bad Execution (Novice Category)
d) Good Idea + Good Execution (Winner category)

Of course, you want to be in the “Winner” quadrant but you may not always start there. More than anything, you should clearly know what category you are currently in.

4. Who you do it with is equally important as what you do with the idea.

People who pitch ideas are extremely interested in “pitching” ideas, of course.I am usually more interested in “who” is pitching more than the idea itself. In fact, in the first meeting, we may not even get to the idea.I want to know who is on the team, their backgrounds, how they came together, their attitudes, why they want to build this company together and even to the extent of getting to know what they want to get out of their life and how this company will play a part in it.

More often, I don’t need to get to that second meeting. It is very clear that some teams can’t execute on this or any other idea.

5. You need a healthy appetite for risk

Moving from being an employee to an entrepreneur requires you to take an enormous amount of risk. You may never have seen that kind of risk as an employee.

Statistics show that the chances of you succeeding as an entrepreneur are very slim. In fact, if you are very logical and want to be an entrepreneur, I suggest that you don’t look at the statistics at all. They don’t look pretty.

I see too many people trying to play safe. It’s almost like they are saying “I will start working full-time in my new business once I am VERY clear that I can take home a reasonable amount of money every month.” In reality, the scenario may be that you have to work full-time in your business in order to increase your chances of taking home a resonable amount of money every month. There is no guarantee there and that is where your appetite for risk comes in.

In closing, I want to wish all those wannabe entrerpeneurs the very best!


Related Articles:

Posted in the Business Models, Main Page category.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend   

10 Comments so far, Add Yours

Anonymous  on August 22nd, 2006

Spot on, Rajesh. If I had a nickel for each time I had to explain to an entrepreneur that it’s the *implementation* that’s important, not the idea, and that ideas really are a dime a dozen… :-)

Anonymous  on August 22nd, 2006

I thought this was a fantastic post! I think anyone who runs a small business or gets comments like these quite frequently. I know I’ve heard them often enough…!

Anonymous  on August 23rd, 2006

Good idea + ‘Bad’ execution = Novice

The article has it as Good idea + Good execution = Novice.

Anonymous  on August 24th, 2006

Great post. Spectator entrepreneurs help make events like that cheaper, they serve and economic purpose for us.

Anonymous  on August 27th, 2006

Dave, Bill, Manoj and Hans:

Thank you for your comments.

I love the term “spectator entrepreneurs” and in one of the emails I got, the term used was “armchair entrepreneurs”

Have a great week ahead!



Pre-stealing ideas | Life Beyond Code  on December 7th, 2008

[…] Life Beyond Code: Help – someone stole my idea! […]

I Had That Idea! « Official Website of Justin S. King  on July 2nd, 2009

[…] One More:  Someone Stole My Idea! […]

Dave Doolin  on November 19th, 2009

By your definition, I’m definitely clueless. The numbers don’t lie.

But I’d rather be pounding through my ignorance poorly executing a bad idea than dreaming about fortune and glory. And not doing anything about it.

Back to the salt mine.

Rajesh Setty  on November 19th, 2009

Dave, please take care there. I am sure you are doing quite well.

Thanks for chipping in here.



9 Reasons Why Many Smart People Go Nowhere | Life Beyond Code  on March 31st, 2010

[…] will steal their ideas and they won’t share them. So it’s a double loss there. If they stop worrying about others stealing their idea and start executing, it will be a whole new world out […]

Leave a Comment